What Kind of Cookies Would You Put in a Beetlejuice Cookie Jar?

I've never seen a Beetlejuice cookie jar before. It makes me smile. There are currently four of them available on eBay.

What kind of cookies would you put in here? Black-and-white Oreos aren't close enough to the theme, and I'm not talented enough to create a Lydia Deets face cookie. Maybe a Beetlejuice gingerbread man?